baydee Door and window picture

best replacement windows consumer reports: Factors to Consider

If you're planning to replace your old and drafty windows, you're in for a treat because the replacement window industry today offers a diverse selection of high-quality, energy-efficient windows. However, with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to decide which replacement windows are best for your home. Luckily, there is a reliable resource out there that can help you make that decision – Consumer Reports.

Consumer Reports is an independent, non-profit organization that aims to provide unbiased product testing and reviews to consumers. Their ratings and reviews of replacement windows are based on factors such as durability, energy efficiency, ease of use, and value for money. Here are some of the key factors you should consider when looking for the best replacement windows, based on Consumer Reports' ratings.


One of the most important factors to consider when choosing replacement windows is their energy efficiency. Windows that are energy-efficient can help you save money on your energy bills and reduce your carbon footprint. Consumer Reports typically recommends windows that have the Energy Star label, which indicates the window has met certain standards for energy efficiency set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Window Materials

The type of material your windows are made of can have a significant impact on their energy efficiency, durability, and appearance. Consumer Reports typically recommends vinyl replacement windows because they offer good insulation and are low-maintenance. However, if you're looking for a more upscale look, wood-clad windows may be a better option.

Window Styles

Another factor to consider is the style of your replacement windows. Consumer Reports recommends double-hung windows for their traditional look and ease of use, as they allow you to open both the top and bottom sash. Other popular window styles include casement windows, which swing out for easy cleaning, and sliding windows, which move horizontally along a track.

Brand Reputation

When it comes to replacing windows, it's important to choose a reputable brand that stands behind their products. Consumer Reports provides ratings and reviews for various window brands, including Pella, Andersen, Marvin, and Simonton. These brands have a reputation for producing high-quality windows that are durable, energy-efficient, and aesthetically pleasing.


Finally, it's essential to choose a professional window installer who can properly install your replacement windows. Poor installation can not only result in energy loss, but it can also compromise the security and safety of your home. Consumer Reports recommends getting multiple quotes and checking references before hiring a window installer.

best replacement windows consumer reports: Top Picks

Based on the factors above, here are some of Consumer Reports' top picks for replacement windows:

1. Pella 350 Series: These vinyl windows received top marks in Consumer Reports' tests for durability, air leakage, and ease of use.

2. Andersen 400 Series: Made of high-quality wood and fiberglass, these windows are energy-efficient and offer excellent protection against the elements.

3. Marvin Infinity: These fiberglass windows offer superior insulation and strength, making them ideal for harsh weather conditions.

4. Simonton Prism Platinum: These vinyl windows are energy-efficient and come with a lifetime warranty, making them a great value for money.

5. Renewal by Andersen: Known for their custom sizes and great service, Renewal by Andersen offers wood-clad windows that are both energy-efficient and aesthetically pleasing.

In Conclusion

Replacing your old and drafty windows with new, energy-efficient ones can significantly improve your home's comfort and energy efficiency. However, with so many options available, it's important to do your research and choose the best replacement windows for your needs. By considering the factors outlined above and looking at Consumer Reports' ratings and reviews, you can make an informed decision that will benefit your home for years to come.